Actual Cash Value (ACV)
Also called: ACV, depreciated value
Actual Cash Value is what the damaged property was worth at the moment it was damaged: replacement cost minus depreciation for age and wear. On a roof that means an eighteen-year-old shingle is valued as an eighteen-year-old shingle, not as a new one.
What it means
Actual cash value is the value of the damaged property immediately before it was damaged. The usual way of arriving at it is to take the cost of replacing the item new and subtract depreciation for its age, wear, and remaining useful life.
Applied to a roof, the logic is straightforward even when the result is unwelcome. A shingle roof has a finite life. A roof most of the way through that life is worth considerably less than a new one, and actual cash value reflects that. The insurer is valuing what was actually lost, which was an old roof, not the new roof that will replace it.
Why the first cheque is a shock
This is the single most common source of anger on a storm claim, and it is almost always an information problem rather than a dispute.
A homeowner is given a contractor’s estimate for a full roof replacement. Some weeks later a payment arrives that is a fraction of it. Nothing has gone wrong: the payment is the actual cash value, reduced by depreciation and then by the deductible, and on an older roof those two deductions can account for a very large share of the estimate.
Whether the rest ever arrives depends on which kind of policy the homeowner holds, and most homeowners do not know which they hold. Under a replacement cost policy the withheld depreciation is generally recoverable once the work is completed and documented. Under an actual cash value policy it is not: the ACV payment is the settlement.
That difference is worth many thousands of dollars and it is printed on the declarations page, not decided by the adjuster.
Where ACV shows up deliberately
Some policies are written on an actual cash value basis for the roof specifically, even where the rest of the dwelling is insured for replacement cost. This is common on older roofs and appears as an endorsement or a roof settlement schedule. Under such an endorsement the payment scales with the roof’s age, and an old roof can settle for a small proportion of replacement cost.
None of that is decided when the claim is made. It was decided when the policy was written or renewed, which is why the declarations page and its endorsements are the first documents to look at on any roof claim.
Common mistakes
Quoting a homeowner an expected payment from an estimate is the worst one. The estimate is replacement cost; the first payment will not be.
The second is assuming a replacement cost policy. Plenty of roofs are insured on an actual cash value basis, and telling a homeowner the rest is coming when it is not is a conversation nobody recovers from.
The third is confusing depreciation with the deductible. They are separate deductions, applied for different reasons, and both come off before the cheque.
On the call
When a homeowner says the cheque was nowhere near the estimate, this is usually the reason and they have not been told. Do not quote figures, but do explain the shape: the first payment is the depreciated value, and whether the rest is recoverable depends on their policy. That one sentence defuses most angry calls.
This is how our agents handle it on storm appointment calls and day-to-day roofing answering service intake.
Questions people ask about actual cash value
- Why is the ACV cheque so much smaller than the roofer's estimate?
- Because the estimate prices a new roof and the ACV payment reflects the value of the old one. Depreciation for age and wear is subtracted, and the deductible comes off as well. On an older roof those two deductions together can be a large share of the total.
- Is ACV the final payment?
- It depends on the policy. Under a replacement cost policy the withheld depreciation is usually recoverable once the work is done and documented, so ACV is the first of two payments. Under an actual cash value policy it is the settlement, and there is no second payment.
- Does the roof's age change the ACV?
- Substantially. Depreciation is applied against the age and condition of what was damaged, so the older the roof, the larger the deduction and the smaller the ACV payment. Two identical storms on two identical houses produce very different first cheques if the roofs are different ages.
Back to the full roofing claims glossary.