Non-Recoverable Depreciation
Also called: non-recoverable depreciation, permanent depreciation
Non-Recoverable Depreciation is depreciation the carrier deducts and will never pay back, however the repair goes. It arises under actual cash value policies and under roof settlement endorsements, and it means the homeowner funds the gap between the settlement and the job.
What it means
Depreciation is the reduction applied to a claim to reflect the age and wear of what was damaged. On many claims that reduction is temporary: it is withheld and released once the work is done. Non-recoverable depreciation is the version that is not released. It is deducted, and it stays deducted.
The practical consequence is a gap. The claim pays the depreciated value; the roof costs the full value; the homeowner covers the difference out of pocket.
Where it comes from
Two situations produce it, and both are decided by the policy rather than by the adjuster.
The first is an actual cash value policy. Some dwellings, particularly older ones or those in high-risk markets, are insured on an ACV basis, in which case the depreciated settlement is the whole entitlement.
The second is a roof-specific endorsement on a policy that is otherwise replacement cost. These appear under names like roof settlement schedules or actual cash value loss settlement for roof surfaces, and they commonly scale the settlement with the age of the roof: the older the covering, the greater the permanent reduction. The rest of the house may still be insured for replacement cost while the roof is not.
Neither of these is a decision made at claim time. Both were set when the policy was written or renewed, which is why the declarations page and its endorsement list are the first things to look at.
Why it matters early rather than late
A homeowner with recoverable depreciation has a cash-flow problem: the money comes in two instalments and the second one arrives after the work. A homeowner with non-recoverable depreciation has a funding problem: some of the money is never coming at all.
Those require completely different conversations, and the difference is knowable at the beginning from the policy documents. Discovering it after a contract is signed and a crew is scheduled is how jobs stall halfway and how customers end up feeling misled by everyone involved.
Common mistakes
Assuming replacement cost coverage because it is the more common arrangement is the main one. It is common, not universal, and the exceptions cluster precisely on older roofs in storm-exposed markets, which is to say on a large share of storm claims.
The second is quoting a job against the estimate rather than against the settlement, where the two are structurally different numbers.
The third is treating non-recoverable depreciation as something to argue about. It is generally not an adjuster’s judgement call but a term of the policy, and time spent disputing it is time not spent helping the homeowner plan around it.
On the call
If a homeowner's depreciation is non-recoverable, they have a funding gap and the sooner they know the size of it the better. Do not calculate it for them, but do flag the question early: whether the depreciation is recoverable is on the policy, and a job priced on the assumption that it is recoverable can strand a customer.
This is how our agents handle it on storm appointment calls and day-to-day roofing answering service intake.
Questions people ask about non-recoverable depreciation
- How does a homeowner know if their depreciation is recoverable?
- The settlement documents normally label it, and the policy determines it. An actual cash value policy, or a roof settlement endorsement on an otherwise replacement cost policy, produces non-recoverable depreciation. The declarations page and its endorsement list are where that shows up.
- Can non-recoverable depreciation be appealed?
- It is not usually an adjuster decision to appeal. It follows from the policy the homeowner bought, so there is rarely anything to dispute unless the carrier has applied the wrong basis. Where a homeowner believes the wrong settlement basis was used, that is a question to put to the carrier directly.
- Does non-recoverable depreciation mean the roof cannot be replaced?
- No, but it means the insurance will not cover the whole cost. The homeowner funds the difference between the settlement and the job. Knowing that number early is what lets them plan, which is why the question belongs at the start of the process and not at the end.
Back to the full roofing claims glossary.