Umpire
Also called: appraisal umpire
Umpire is the neutral third party selected by the two appraisers in an appraisal to break a deadlock over the amount of a loss. An award signed by any two of the three participants normally binds, which makes the umpire's view decisive when the appraisers disagree.
What it means
When a claim goes to appraisal, each side appoints an appraiser. Often the two of them reach agreement and that is the end of it. When they do not, the process needs a tie-breaker, and that is the umpire: a neutral third party the two appraisers select between them.
The award mechanism is what gives the role its weight. An award signed by any two of the three normally binds. So the umpire does not need to persuade both appraisers; they need to agree with one. In a deadlocked appraisal, the umpire’s assessment therefore tends to become the outcome.
How selection works
The appraisers agree on a name. In practice this is a negotiation of its own, because both sides understand how much the choice matters, and each has a sense of which umpires tend toward which kinds of conclusions.
Where they cannot agree, policies typically allow either party to apply to a court for an appointment. That adds time and cost, which is one reason appraisers usually find a way to agree.
The qualification that matters is competence and disinterest. An umpire with no connection to either side and genuine familiarity with the type of loss is what the process assumes.
What the umpire actually decides
The amount, and only the amount. The umpire in a property appraisal is not there to rule on whether hail caused the damage, whether an exclusion applies, or whether the carrier handled the claim properly. Those are coverage and conduct questions and they sit outside appraisal.
In a roof appraisal the practical content is scope and pricing: how many squares, which components, what the regional pricing supports, how depreciation was applied. The umpire is reading two documents that disagree and forming a view about the correct figure.
Because two signatures bind, the result frequently lands between the two positions rather than adopting either. That is worth understanding before entering the process: a party that has taken an extreme position may find the midpoint less attractive than the settlement it refused.
Where a contractor sits
Well outside. Appraisal is a contractual mechanism between the homeowner and the carrier, and the umpire is selected by appraisers, not by claimants or their trades.
The contribution that matters is upstream: documentation good enough that the homeowner’s appraiser can make the case. An appraiser working from photographs, measurements, and a defensible scope has something to argue. One working from an estimate total does not.
Common mistakes
Expecting the umpire to rule on coverage is the most common, and it produces an award that answers a question nobody needed answered.
The second is treating the process as adversarial theatre. Appraisers and umpires work from documents, and the side with better documents does better.
The third is under-estimating the cost and time before invoking it.
On the call
An umpire only exists once a claim is deep into appraisal, so a caller mentioning one is describing a formal dispute rather than a routine claim. Do not attempt to advise. Capture the position accurately and route it to the owner or claims lead the same day.
This is how our agents handle it on storm appointment calls and day-to-day roofing answering service intake.
Questions people ask about umpire
- Who chooses the umpire?
- The two appraisers select one between them. Where they cannot agree, the policy typically provides for a court to appoint one on application. The selection matters, because the umpire frequently ends up deciding the number when the appraisers are far apart.
- Does the umpire have to agree with one of the appraisers?
- No. An award requires two signatures out of three, so the umpire and either appraiser can settle the amount between them, and that figure need not match either appraiser's original position. Umpires commonly land somewhere neither side proposed.
- Is the umpire the same as an arbitrator?
- Not exactly, although both resolve disputes outside court. The umpire's role is defined by the policy's appraisal provision and is confined to the amount of the loss, whereas arbitration under other agreements can be much broader. Confusing the two leads to expectations appraisal cannot meet.
Back to the full roofing claims glossary.